Invest periodically or all at once?
Thursday, November 4th, 2004
Categorized as: Yesterday's News (old post archive)
I'm interested in putting away $20,000 for 20 to 30 years. Does it make any difference whether I put it all away at once or whether I invest say a thousand dollars a month over a 20-month period? Will my timing affect the amount I earn in the end?
Tom's response
You have an interesting question. If we were talking about stocks, mutual funds, or fixed-rate investments like traditional bonds or bank certificates of deposit, I would encourage you to invest a little bit at a time on a scheduled basis.
This is a low-risk strategy that causes you to obtain the average cost over the period you make the investment. You do lose the chance to accidentally buy in at a cost advantage, but, more importantly, you escape the risk of buying in at a cost disadvantage.
However, Savings Bonds are different. The interest rate you receive on Savings Bonds is adjusted every six months. So you're not locking yourself into a specific rate or - in stock market terms - a specific price.
Because Savings Bonds rates adjust, your returns get averaged out whether you invest all at once or on a scheduled basis. So the answer to your question is that with Savings Bonds, it doesn't make any difference.
(Average rating: 5 stars)
Loading ...
Tom,
All good points for the above questioner who plans to leave the I-Bonds untouched for 20-30 years.
However, if one is planning to count I-Bonds toward their "Emergency Fund", then the one-year redemption rule clearly makes it advantageous to move gradually to I-Bonds from a more liquid source.
I'm taking a little bit at the end of each month from my online savings account into Treasury Direct. I don't plan to redeem until it matures, but if I have to I'll know I have access to most of it. So far, it's proven a much better option for that universally suggested 3-6 months of living expenses than savings accounts, short-term CD's, or T-bills!
Dan - thanks for making that point. The one-year redemption rule is an angle I didn't think of when I answered this question.
In addition, since I wrote the answer the way EE bonds work has changed and the rates on new ones don't adjust.
And with I bonds, the fixed base-rate doesn't adjust.
All of these are reasons to invest periodically rather than all at once.